Charles Octavius Boothe (1877)
J. C. Curry (Fourth Pastor)
Albert Franklin Owens (fifth Pastor)
Robert Thomas Pollard (1892-1895)
Jacob Tileston Brown (1896-1897)
William H. McAlpine (1899-1904)
W. W. Colley (Twelfth Pastor)
Robert Chapman Judkins (1905-1916)
Peter Andrew Callahan (1917-1926)*
Frank Walter Jacob (1926-1932)*
Arnold Erasmus Gregory (1932-1939)*
Ralph Waldo Riley (1940-1944)*
A. C. Livingston Arbouin (1946)*
Herbert H. Eaton (1960-1965)*
Dr. G. Murray Branch (1966-1972 & 1977-1989)*
Robert M. Dickerson (1973-1977)*
Boykin Sanders (1990-1991)*
Richard W. Wills, Sr. (1992-1995)*
Michael F. Thurman (1996-2011)
Cromwell Handy (2013-2022)
